The withdrawal of the charge ‘attempting murder of a policeman in duty’ against the “HINDRAF 31”, which lead to the acquittal of these 31 suspects on Monday, 17 December 2007 at the Shah Alam Sessions Court was really shameful and disgrace to the Attorney General’s Chambers. This decision was made almost immediately after 13 ethnic Indian NGOs and defacto Indian community leader and MIC President Dato’ Seri S. Samy Vellu met the ‘Flip-Flop’ Prime Minister Dato’ Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi late last week.
Some people actually thought the charge of ‘attempting murder on a policeman’ was overkill, despite a life of a policeman on duty, to maintain order and public safety was grievously threatened by a mob of 31 people. Enough to allow some really opportunistically-bankrupt-dinosaur-relic politician to demand that the Attorney General to apologise to the ‘HINDRAF 31’, despite that they were initially denied bail for the severity of the charge then ‘conveniently’ let of the hook with lightning speed because the ‘Flip-Flop’ Prime Minister ‘compassionately’ intervened into the legal process. This arrogantly ungrateful call shoul be seen as ‘adding insult to injury’.
Taken from Malaysia-Today.net:
|
Gani owes public apology to Batu Caves 31 for travesty of justice |
|
Posted by Raja Petra |
||
Tuesday, 18 December 2007 |
||
Gani owes the Batu Caves 31 unjustly incarcerated for 13 days – a total of 403 days – and their families a public apology.The Attorney-General Tan Sri Gani Patail owes the Batu Caves 31 who were unjustly incarcerated for 13 days and their families a public apology for the sufferings and hardships they should not have been made to go through.Gani’s explanations why he dropped the charges of attempted murder against the Batu Caves 31 in the Shah Alam Sessions Court underline the grave injustice which the Attorney-General had caused the 31 with the ridiculous charge of attempted murder and collective punishment of the 31 with the denial of bail for 13 days, resulting in a number of victims losing their jobs.Two reasons had been given by Gani.Gani said: “We can’t pinpoint who exactly did it or rather who was the one who threw the brick at the person who was badly injured”. If so, why did he charge the 31 with the capital offence of “attempted murder” with the maximum sentence of 20 years’ jail and fine, and what’s worse, denying bail to them for 13 days on a completely baseless contention of their being threats to national security!Secondly, Gani said the 31 men were initially charged not because they were alleged to be Hindraf members but because they had committed an offence by participating in an illegal assembly.Gani said all the 31 men had signed letters opposing Hindraf and claimed they were not Hindraf members. They also said they would never take part in any illegal assembly in the future.This is a very serious contradiction. If the 31 were not charged because they were Hindraf members, why should any subsequent claim that they were not Hindraf members have any bearing on their cases?The Batu Caves 31 had already been harshly and unfairly punished although they were innocent of the charge of attempted murder, as they were all incarcerated for 13 days each, which work out to 403 days for jail sentence for the 31.The least Gani should do is to tender a public apology to the Batu Caves 31 and their families for this travesty of justice and abuse of prosecutorial powers in his unfair and unjust handling of cases of the Batu Caves 31.Lim Kit Siang |
On the other hand, some other people thought that the HINDRAF leaders and active supporters were likened as ‘extremist militants’, equivalent to Al Maunah, KMM and Communist Terrorists and should be dealt severely. Some UMNO leaders vehemently asked the Government and authorities to deal with these people stern and decisively. One even charged them with guilt of ‘high treason’.
Almost two weeks ago, 397 NGOs from all the major ethnic groups, interests and level of the Malaysian society converged and adopted a resolution for the Government to seriously consider.
Despite warnings and threats of arrest and after 18 days of allowing the HINDRAF leaders to go around making more incriminating statements and defying provisions of the law and societal norms on maintaining harmony and good inter-racial relations, last Thursday five HINDRAF leaders were arrested under ISA laws. This were received with relieved by many and dismay by some.
Having said all that, there are people who felt that not only the HINDRAF leaders and active supporters could be charged, tried and eventually found guilty of ‘extremist militanism’, seditions and high treason, but guilty of unbecoming the citizen of Malaysia and be stripped of the citizenship to this country. This is provided by the Constitution of the Federation of Malaysia, Article 25 (1) A which read:
Article 25
- (1) The Federal Government may by order deprive of his citizenship any person who is a citizen by registration under Article 16A or 17 or a citizen by naturalisation if satisfied –
- (a) that he has shown himself by act or speech to be disloyal or disaffected towards the Federation;
Clearly, HINDRAF leaders, especially the five-plus-one, committed enough grounds for the warrant to be stripped of their Malaysian citizenship. In his letter to the British Prime Minister Gordon Brown on 15 November 2007, HINDRAF leader P. Uthayakumar urged that Malaysia’s membership in the Commonwealth be suspended, if not expelled for blatant lies and malicious fabricated information about Malaysian Indian ethnic being systematically and structurally put through the “ethnic cleansing” process the last fifty years. Of course, the HINDRAF primary objective was to stir up the anger of the Indian ethnic group, worldwide. Then it was the piece that was featured as the front page in a Singapore daily that violence is imminent, in the HINDRAF roll-out plan. That is not including statements made whilst abroad, including in the UK and India, where it almost caused a diplomatic row.
These attempts are nothing less that of as per stated as “…he (they has (have) shown himself (themselves) by act or speech, to be disloyal or disaffect towards the Federation”.
This opportunity would be the perfect ‘consolation’, if not ‘redemption’ for the overwhelmingly disgraceful and intolerable “cock-up” by the ‘Flip-Flop’ Prime Minister Abdullah via Attorney General Tan Sri Gani Patail. Failure to act against these persons who have committed “crimes of disloyal towards the Federation”, especially when one is provided with the law to do so, shall be deemed as collaborating with the said criminals too. Therefore, one should be subjected to be de-citizenise too, as provided by Article 25 (1) A of the Constitution of the Federation.
Erti “Korban” melayari sepanjang 1428H
Hari ini, umat Islam diMalaysia akan menyambut Hari Raya Aidil Adha atau Hari Raya Qurban, 1428H. Walaupun wukuf diArafah ialah pada hari Selasa 18 Disember 2007, namun Majlis Raja Raja telah menetapkan bahawa Khamis 20 Disember 2007.
Sambutan “Korban” yang dirayakan umat Islam seluruh dunia ialah apabila memperingati sejarah Allah s.w.t. memfirmankan Nabi Ibrahim A.S. untuk menyembelihkan anakandanya sendiri, Nabi Ismail A.S. Sebagai seorang Rasul yang taat kepada Pencipta seluruh alam semesta yang tidak berbelah bagi itu, Ibrahim A.S. menurut perintah Allah s.w.t. tanpa ragu ragu walaupun syaitan cuba mempengaruhi agar hambaNya itu meragui perintah Tuhan.
Dalam masyarakat Melayu-Islam Malaysia moden, “Korban” musim Zulhijjah ini membawa maksud apabila orang orang berkemampuan bersedekah ternakan seperti lembu, kerbau, kambing dan kadang kala dewasa ini, unta, untuk sedikit ‘kemewahan’ dan nikmat kepada golongan kurang berada dan bernasib baik. “Korban” ialah ibadah tahunan yang meneruskan pengertian mengenang, membantu dan meringankan sedikit permasalahan orang lain, terutama masyarakat sekeliling kita dan rakan-taulan dan saudara-mara terdekat.
Walaubagaimanapun, “Korban” kali ini disenarai dari sudut majoriti yang ‘berkorban’ untuk kepentingan segelintir, termasuk dari perspektif peribadi. Blog ini ingin menyingkap erti “Korban” secara kasar dan sekali lalu, dari sudut politik tanahair dalam tempoh setahun ini.
Setahun ini, “Korban” membawa pengertian lain dan konnotasi negatif. Tahun 1428H ini memperlihatkan berpuluh ribu umat Islam dan rakyat Malaysia, berada dalam serba kekurangan dan kesusahan serta cabaran amat getir apabila Selatan Semenanjung Malaysia dilanda bencana banjir besar bermula lewat tahun 2006, sedangkan Perdana Menterinya berdendang bercuti dan bersantai disamping keluarga dan sahabat terdekat diPerth, Australia, termasuk dengan besar hati merasmikan sebuah restoran nasi kandar.
Dalam tahun ini juga, menyaksikan rakyat Malaysia ber”Korban”, melalui syarikat milik penuh Kerajaan, Penerbangan Malaysia Berhad membelanjakan RM 200 juta sebuah pesawat eksekutif serba mewah baru sedangkan TUDM beroperasi dengan tiga buah pesawat eksekutif mewah lain sediada.
Mantan Perdana Menteri dan Presiden UMNO Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad mengesa ahli ahli UMNO agar sedia untuk ‘mengorbankan’ Kepimpinan, demi UMNO dan kepentingan taktikal dan strategik orang orang Melayu, semasa berada diJohor Bahru, bandaraya kelahiran UMNO, pada 10 Februari 2007.
Kepentingan strategik Melayu dalam Wilayah Pembangunan Iskandar (satu plan pembangunan mega-gergasi yang sangat bercita cita tinggi, dilancarkan November 2006 sempena nama DYMM Sultan Iskandar Al Haj Ibni Almarhum Sultan Ismail, Sultan Johor), secara terbuka diperjelaskan akan di”korban”kan secara terancang dan berstruktur, dalam satu wawancara bersama Pengerusi panel penasihat IDRA mantan Timbalan Perdana Menteri Tun Musa Hitam.
Kemudian, Tun Dr. Mahathir juga apabila secara terbuka “memberikan sokongan” kepada satu masa dulu seteru politik semasa dalam UMNO iaitu Tengku Tan Sri Razaleigh Hamzah, kini sedia ‘mengorbankan’ kepentingan peribadi dalam satu syarahan diUniversiti Malaya dan mengimbau kembali pemikiran Allahyarham Tun Abdul Razak Hussein.
Rakyat Malaysia juga ter”korban” apabila orang kepercayaan Perdana Menteri Kalimullah Hassan dan menantu PM Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, Khairy Jamaluddin ‘bermain silap mata dan sandiwara-panggung bangsawan semata mata’ apabila mengumumkan kembalinya mereka dalam ECM Libra setelah kunun kunun ‘menjualkan kepentingan mereka’ dalam syarikat bank pelaburan butik itu Ogos tahun lepas, selepas skandal ‘ECM Libra-Avenue Capital’ hebat diperkatakan.
Kronisma dalam pentadbiran PM Abdullah mula menjejaskan rakyat, termasuk DYMM Seri Paduka Baginda Yang DiPertuan Agong apabila sistem diLapangan Terbang Sultan Mahmud, Kuala Terengganu rosak dan semua penerbangan dibatalkan/tunda.
Proton, sebuah syarikat berteknologi tinggi dan pemangkin utama Negara kedalam industri pembuatan mekanikal dan status negara maju, yang telah perlahan lahan dibina dengan pelaburan besar, keringat dan pengorbanan banyak imbuhan rakyat Malaysia, di’korban’kan secara sistematik dalam pentadbiran PM Abdullah.
Abdullah Ahmad Badawi yang kematian isteri, berkahwin semula dengan Jeanne Abdullah pada Jun tahun ini. Sempena perkahwinan ini, satu analisa kepimpinan sebagai Perdana Menteri yang telah disenaraikan oleh seorang mantan pegawai Jabatan Perdana Menteri, telah diterbitkan semula dalam blog ini, sebagai ‘hadiah perkahwinan’.
PM Abdullah juga cuba ‘mengorbankan ‘ memori, keyakinan dan kepercayaan rakyat Malaysia kepada Bapa Pembangunan Malaysia Allahyarham Tun Abdul Razak Hussein apabila menyamakan diri beliau kepada Perdana Menteri Malaysia ke II itu.
“Korban” juga membawa erti bahawa Mantan Perdana Menteri Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad sanggup “mengaku kesilapan memilih penganti” apabila mengulangi kenyataan konsisten mengenai kepincangan pentadbiran PM Abdullah sehingga sampai keperingkat “menjadi busuk”, termasuk mengulas kenyatan mantan Ketua Polis Negara Tun Mohd. Hanif Omar mengenai pasukan Polis dewasa ini.
‘Kiblat’ dasar luar negara juga telah menjadi “Korban” dizaman pentadbiran PM Abdullah walaupun beliau sendiri pernah menjadi Menteri Luar Negeri selama 8 tahun dalam pentadbiran Tun Dr. Mahathir.
Ada pihak pihak yang sengaja melupakan sejarah ‘pengorbanan’ dan peranan utama yang dimainkan orang orang Melayu untuk mencapai Kemerdekaan, termasuk kesediaan untuk ‘bertolak-ansur’ dan ‘berkongsi-kuasa’.
“Korban” ialah apabila Malaysia diperlihatkan bagaimana Menteri Kewangan membentangkan Bajet 2008 diDewan Rakyat yang tidak konsisten dan apabila ditanya pemberita, secara selamba meminta perkara itu dirujuk kepada Menteri Kewangan II.
“Melayu mudah lupa” merupakan pesan Presiden UMNO Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad yang terpapar sebagai realiti, ditafsirkan dengan perbuatan “mengorbankan” jasa dan kenangan keatas ‘orang tua’ di”korban”kan sama sekali.
Telekom Malaysia merupakan asset Negara yang paling terkini sekali di”korban”kan, terutama dari sudut pembangunan Negara dan masyarakat. Syarikat GLC yang menjadi salah satu tunggak KLCI kini mengorak langkah kearah memfokus kepada ‘keuntungan, pulangan pelaburan, penambahan nilai dan kedudukan menguasai pasaran’ melampau objektif utama dan asal syarikayt ini diujudkan, bina dan korporatkan.
22 Oktober lepas merupakan genap setahun pertemuan-empat-mata Perdana Menteri dan mantan Perdana Menteri dimana 19 point telah diutarakan sebagai bahan perbincangan. Sehingga hari ini, rakyat Malaysia masih belum lihat perkembangan permasalahan yang menjadi perhatian begitu banyak pihak dalam segala aduan yang dimajukan itu.
Masyarakat Malaysia telah diingatkan semula mengenai seluruh “Korban” yang Negara tempuhi selama empat tahun dibawah pentadbiran PM Abdullah Ahmad Badawi.
Setiausaha Politik Menteri Kewangan Ke II dan ahli MKT UMNO yang dilantik, Dato’ Mohd. Norza Zakaria pula cuba ‘mengorbankan’ pemikiran dan kuasa-minda orang orang Melayu apabila salah mendefinisikan cara pentadbiran dan kewibawaan kepimpinan PM Abdullah Ahmad Badawi.
Ada ahli UMNO yang sedia ‘berkorban’ dan membelakangkan kepentingan peribadi, apabila membuat laporan Polis mengenai Presiden UMNO Dato’ Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi mengenai “Konspirasi diperingkat tertinggi mengagalkan mantan Presiden UMNO Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad dipilih sebagai Perwakilan UMNO Kubang Pasu 9 September 2006”, sewaktu Perhimpunan Agung UMNO tahun 2007.
Terbaru ini, dunia diperlihatkan Perdana Menteri ‘Flip-Flop’ mengarahkan Peguam Negara dengan kadar segera untuk menimbang semula semua pertuduhan ‘HINDRAF 31’, selepas 13 NGO Hindu dan Presiden MIC bertemu beliau. Menjelang Isnin, Mahkamah Sesyen Shah Alam membebaskan 31 orang yang dituduh cuba membunuh seorang anggota Polis semasa bertugas walaupun sebelum itu, Peguam Negara yang sama memohon mahkamah untuk menafikan jaminan kerana ‘kes yang berat’.
Ini sekaligus mengkhianati prinsip ‘Rule of Law‘ yang wajar dilaksanakan tanpa ‘memilih bulu’ dan tradisi semua Perdana Menteri Malaysia sebelum ini yang membuat keputusan demi kepentingan Negara dan rakyat dan bukan populariti politik dan peribadi.
“Korban” kini jelas membawa pengertian yang berbeza untuk rakyat Malaysia dan orang orang Melayu, yang rata rata berugama Islam sempena menyambut pesta “Qurban” setahun ini.