Crack in Ketuanan Rakyat


The twist into the ‘political pantomime’, resulted from the defection of Bota ADUN into PKR two weeks ago thickens. It seems the ‘marriage of inconvenience’ between DAP-PKR-PAS has now proven itself to be an ‘unholy alliance’. There is a crack amongst the ‘Ketuanan Rakyat’ people.

DAP Chairman Karpal Singh has asked party-less Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim to no longer be the defacto leader of the Pakatan Rakyat.

The Star has the story:

Karpal asks Anwar to step down

GEORGE TOWN: Pakatan Rakyat de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim should step down for causing trouble in the coalition, DAP national chairman Karpal Singh said.

The Bukit Gelugor MP is blaming Anwar for “creating trouble,” and said that the former deputy prime minister “needed to repent without further betraying the people and their trust.”

He said Pakatan Rakyat needed another leader, a good leader, and lashed out at PKR and DAP leaders who had fallen sway to Anwar’s rhetoric in supporting crossovers of elected representatives.

“I am not getting the support from my own party leaders, neither party adviser Lim Kit Siang nor secretary-general Lim Guan Eng, on the party-hopping issue.

“It seems that they are supporting Anwar instead of me. I am the party chairman, don’t push me too far as I still have the support of the rank and file,’’ he told a press conference at his office near here Sunday.

Asked if he was thinking of calling for an emergency meeting on the future of the party in the coalition, Karpal Singh said he was thinking of doing so.

“I can’t fight the DAP cause alone. What I am saying is the truth, and eventually the truth prevails. I have said before that DAP should seriously consider getting out of the coalition and I repeat my stand once again today.

“Party-hopping can never be justified as it can be compared with one murdering the very parents who were responsible for one’s birth merely upon one reaching adulthood,’’ he added.

He said he was confounded by how Anwar could have openly espoused and encouraged crossovers after the people gave a resounding mandate to the Pakatan Rakyat during the last elections.

He noted that Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak had said that it was Anwar who started it all (party-hopping), but added that two wrongs could never make a right.

“For the record Barisan Nasional had accepted crossovers from DAP as far back as 1969, and therefore it is hypocritical for the Deputy Prime Minister to place the blame on Anwar, who in fact joined Barisan in 1981 and rose from the ranks to become the Prime Minister-in-waiting just before his expulsion from the party in 1998.

“I only hope he (Anwar) did not learn of the morality or rather immorality of political kangaroos hopping from the opposition to Barisan during the time he was in government.

“In the public interest, and in particular in the interest of Pakatan Rakyat, Anwar has a lot to answer for in creating the woes of the coalition now,’’ he added.

On the police reports lodged against him by George Town Penang Umno Youth leaders for questioning the rights of the Malay Rulers, Karpal Singh he warned those who have made these reports of the consequences of lodging false reports.

“I am warning them of the consequences … . Enough is enough, if they want trouble then they have come to the right place,” he said in a firm tone.
Karpal said there was nothing illegal or unlawful in what he had stated in relation to the Sultan of Perak being subject to the due process of law, and that he can be sued in court for dismissing the Pakatan Rakyat state government in his official capacity.

“It has been in my view and I reiterate that view that the Sultan of Perak had acted ‘ultra vires’ to the provisions of Article 16(6) of the Perak Constitution,’’ he added.

Anwar is widely credited with knitting the different parties in Pakatan — PKR, DAP and PAS — into the coherent opposition that swept five states from under Barisan Nasional’s feet in the 12th general election last March.
Barisan was also denied a two-thirds majority in Parliament.

However, he spent much of his efforts after that attempting to engineer a massive defection of 31 Members of Parliament (MPs) from Barisan to the opposition, promising a Federal Government takeover by Sept 16 last year.
When that mass defection did not take place, he asked his supporters to be patient, saying it would come.

In the meantime, Anwar had become an MP after his wife and PKR president Datin Seri Dr Wan Azizah Ismail her seat in Permatang Pauh. This paved the way for the former deputy prime minister’s return to parliament after his triumph in the ensuing by-election.

He then became the official Opposition leader.

On Jan 22, Anwar trumpeted the defection of Bota state assemblyman Datuk Nasarudin Hashim who quit Umno to join PKR. Less than 10 days later, Nasarudin jumped ship again to rejoin Umno.

This led to Barisan and Pakatan both holding 28 seats each in the state legislative assembly.

This “double hop,” plus the resignations of DAP assemblyman Hee Yit Foong (Jelapang), and PKR assemblymen Mohd Osman Mohd Jailu (Changkat Jering) and Jamaluddin Mohd Radzi (Behrang), led to Barisan declaring it had the majority.

While the three declared they would remain independent, they also swore allegiance to Barisan, which led to Sultan Azlan Shah declaring Barisan the legitimate state government and declining Pakatan’s call to dissolve the state assembly and hold fresh elections.

PKR last year had proposed restoring some of the legal immunities to the royal families.


This does not come as a surprise. The tri-party have different aspirations and dreams. They want different things. They come together purely because of the anti-BN sentiments, thus they managed to be voted into the Dewan Rakyat last 8 March with an unprecedented achievement.

Fourth Prime Minister Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad did say last year, PR would not last. The word “Pakatan” connotes co-operation of something ‘not good’. It does not take so much brains to figure this out. There are already cracks showing amongst the PR Excos in Selangor and Penang State Governments. The aspirations and eagerness to achieve different things are so apparent, because they have different deliverables by their supporters.

It is widely known that DAP is not comfortable with former abuse-of-power convict Anwar’s strategy to grab the power to the Federal Government via ‘cross overs’. They would rather win it in a contest. It seems in Kinta Valley last Thursday, the PR got a ‘taste of their own medicine’.This is nothing short of a slap in their face.

DAP also is never comfortable with PAS’s plan for Hudud. Since the 1999 General Elections when they decided to work closely against BN, they could never get this right. The Barisan Alternatif they formed changed into the Pakatan Rakyat today, even though the players are all the same. Repackaging and rebranding would never change the fact principally, it was doomed to fail right from the start.

In desperation, PR resorted to being BIADAP from being derhaka and ingkar to HRH Paduka Seri Sultan of Perak. This got majority of Malaysians came out and showed their dismay. As a result, the unholy alliance of PR cracking up is now out in the open.

As they say, “what goes around come around”. How would the rest of the Ketuanan Rakyat promoters react to this? Would there be more contradictory statements, that will clearly depict the crumbling of the ‘unholy alliance’ which will never work in the first place?


Published in: on February 8, 2009 at 18:46  Comments (14)  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

14 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. he he he (ikut cara ketawa TDM)

    Memang dah agak dah BABI akan kena

    he he he

    Inilah dia PR iaitu PENIPU RAKYAT!

    he he he

    Where art thou Brader Anwar?

    Did you see it coming?

    he he he


    Brader Anwar dan konco-konco memang bijak merancang tetapi ALLAH (Tuhan kami yang sebenar) adalah perancang yang MAHA TERHEBAT.

    Mari bertaubat Brader Anwar..

    Kembalilah kepangkuanNya dengan berlaku adil sesama kita

    Buangkan sifat mengadu-domba..

    Itukan perangai Yahudi pengikut IBLIS


    Selepas bertaubat ikuti program anjuran BTN kasi kuat jati diri lagi

    he he he

  2. I doubt so the news published by The Star. Later we will hear on the next day the news something like this:

    The Haprakdaily, Tuesday: Brother Anwar Bin Ibrahim (B.A.B.I) dismissed any news regarding dissatisfaction from DAP Chairman, HRH Capal (or Selipar) Singh pertaining his position as Pakatan Rakyat De Facto Leader. He said, “Karpal never said words like that. It is the media who twist his words. He never ever said like that. I swear to you. Pakatan Leader especially both Lims, Karpal Singh and Haji Hadi love me very much. The BN is trying to split the Pakatan Rakyat (Rapuh)” he said during opening a Gay Club in Bangsar.

  3. If Karpal Singh sues the Sultan for 10 million ringgit, then the Sultan should countersue ……maybe 50 million ringgit….?

  4. … it was actually ‘ketuanan Pakatan Rakyat’ where DAP rules! not ketuanan rakyat.


  6. […] Crack in Ketuanan Rakyat […]

  7. […] Akibat salah congak, kini PR mula mengalami keadaan ‘retak menunggu belah’. […]

  8. […] in Selangor have a slightly more complicated twist than what meets the eye. It is no longer about crack within the Ketuanan Pakatan Rakyat, but more of a story of […]

  9. […] a long one year, PR failed. PR was a marriage on convenience between ‘bandits’ with contradictory dreams and […]

  10. […] Rakyat’s chip is very low and with the recent scandals in Perak, Kedah and Selangor and the fall out within Pakatan Rakyat itself, this is an opportunity they would really want to capitalise. Especially against and destroying the […]

  11. […] (calculated risk), tatkala berlaku kecelaruan dan tanda tanda menunjukan bahawa  kerjasama rapuh PR sudah mula ‘retak menunggu belah’. Keujudan ‘tikam belakang’ dalam PR dewasa ini amat ketara. Kesediaan PAS kembali […]

  12. […] have been issues of backstabbing conspiracies, crack in comradeship and disgareement on policies and stance. Pakatan Rakyat is really what reflected in the word; pakatan, which connotes the […]

  13. […] Failing that, he even issued an ultimatum to party-less Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim, who is also PKR de facto leader. This latest development is part of series of Crack in the Ketuanan Rakyat and Ketuanan Rakyat Conundrum. […]

  14. […] Rakyat cracking up: Strange bedfellows backstabbing each other The Ketuanan Rakyat marriage of convenience is really cracking up. The Pakatan Rakyat (PR) new found strength as a ‘united front’, from an ‘unplanned’ […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: